Late last year, Australia enacted a groundbreaking law banning social media usage for individuals under the age of 16. However, one major exception to this rule has sparked controversy: YouTube. Despite initial expectations that Google’s platform would be included, the Australian government has ruled that YouTube serves as a critical educational tool, thus exempting it from the restrictions. This decision has drawn sharp criticism from social media giants like Meta, TikTok, and Snap.
The Debate Over YouTube’s Educational Value
Australia’s eSafety Commissioner revealed last month that YouTube is the most popular platform for children aged 13 to 15, with nearly three-quarters of this age group using the site in 2024. To maintain control over usage, YouTube now requires under-16 users to be part of a family account with parental oversight. However, the platform’s exemption from the social media ban has caused an uproar, particularly among competitors.
Big Tech Voices Concern Over the Exemption
Tech companies have expressed frustration at what they perceive as an unfair distinction between platforms. Ella Woods-Joyce, TikTok’s director of public policy for Australia and New Zealand, stated, “It is illogical to restrict two platforms while exempting the third. It would be akin to banning the sale of soft drinks to minors but exempting Coca-Cola.” Meta echoed these concerns, accusing the Australian government of lacking transparency and undermining its original intent to protect young people.
Snap’s Position on the Ban
Snap, which has also voiced its opposition, argues that it should not be included in the ban, claiming it operates primarily as a messaging service. The company is calling for a consistent approach in enforcing exclusions across all social media platforms.
As the law is set to take effect later this year, the debate over YouTube’s exemption remains unresolved. Big tech companies are hoping their concerns will lead to a reconsideration of the current approach.
For more details on this story, visit the full article on Engadget.